top of page
Icon_Color.png
Fowler & Tidwell Counseling, Houston Texas

The Pursuer and the Withdrawer: Breaking the Cycle of “Talk Now” vs. “I Need Space”

Nov 12
3 min read

The past few months, the issue of friendships in transition has been a major theme in my work with some of my clients.  In a post-pandemic world, many of them have been focusing on the relationships that feel the easiest and the least full of friction. Their desire for connection has been channeled into dynamics that feels “easy”, which is understandable, but what happens when “easy” also starts to feel challenging? 

To him, the issue was miniscule.  To her, it has become a barrier to maintaining the friendship, which is now all but over. He has asked to talk about what happened and make peace, while she has told him that she is not ready, so he has stopped trying. Breaking the Cycle of “Talk Now” vs. “I Need Space”

One of my clients recently had a falling out with his closest grad school friend, who also happens to be his primary social support as they are finishing their program.  The two of them had a bond that is unique within his academic cohort, and they fell out over something thoughtless and “throw away”.  To him, the issue was miniscule.  To her, it has become a barrier to maintaining the friendship, which is now all but over. He has asked to talk about what happened and make peace, while she has told him that she is not ready, so he has stopped trying.  As he puts it, “I’m not going to chase this.  If you don’t want to be my friend anymore, then begging isn’t going to convince you.”


It’s a very specific example of a very common pattern.  When there is friction in any relationship, whether it’s a marriage, a friendship, a romantic partnership, or a sibling dynamic, each party often has an individual timeline for when to address it, and those timelines often differ a lot.  One person wants distance, time to reflect and develop what they want to say, almost curating their points so they make certain that they present exactly what they want to express.  The other person just wants to tackle the problem, focusing on getting it processed so the relationship can recover and move to the next phase.  Neither party is intentionally trying to hurt or pressure the other, neither side is drawing a line in the sand and refusing to budge, but it somehow ends in a stalemate, anyway.


Both people are acting from a place of good intention.  The person who wants to talk desires a resolution through being heard and, hopefully, validated.  The person who needs space is trying to process their own very powerful emotions so they can engage thoughtfully and without being reactive.  The problem is, the talker perceives this as a slight, not an act of self-protection.  In the talker’s mind, the person who wants space is saying, “My feelings are more important than yours.”  In the mind of the person who wants space, the talker is unfairly pressuring them to come to the table, so they think, “You don’t care about what I have to say because you just want to be right.”  When the talker chases, the person who wants space can feel threatened and misunderstood, so they just withdraw more.  


This pattern is very common, and it can lead to the premature end of an otherwise compatible relationship.  Understanding the motivations of the other person can be helpful to not judge them and not view the situation as hopeless. 

For the talker, negotiating a specific timeline to engage can provide the reassurance that they matter and that their needs are important enough to be given the attention they deserve.  For the person who needs space, being given reasonable time to gather their thoughts and regulate their own emotions can help them feel prepared, which builds a sense of safety.  They come to the table ready for an exchange, not a one-sided resolution, and the talker gains confidence that the other person is being open and direct, not just capitulating to get the conflict over with as soon as possible.  The talk becomes a true negotiation, not on a surrender. Breaking the cycle can start today.


Written by : Deanna Diamond, LPC. To book with Deanna, click here!


Comments


bottom of page